Insurance Agency Employee Screening Requirements Guide
Quick answer: Insurance agencies must screen anyone who will engage in the business of insurance against 18 U.S.C. 1033. That law bars people convicted of felonies involving dishonesty or breach of trust unless the state insurance regulator gives written consent. Agencies must also follow state licensing rules and the FCRA's disclosure, authorization and adverse action steps. Reveal Background runs these checks.
- Federal law (18 U.S.C. 1033) limits who may work in insurance after certain felony convictions; state regulators control consent and licensing.
- Every third-party background check must follow the FCRA: written disclosure, written authorization, and a two-step adverse action process.
- A solid insurance screen combines criminal searches, identity verification, employment and education verification, and, for driving roles, an MVR.
What does federal law require for insurance employees?
Section 1033 of Title 18 of the U.S. Code makes it a federal crime for a person convicted of a felony involving dishonesty or breach of trust to willfully engage in the business of insurance without the written consent of the state insurance regulator. The same section makes it a crime for an insurer to knowingly permit that person to participate. The agency's duty is therefore practical: find out before the person starts work.
Federal law does not prescribe one screening package. Your state insurance department, your carrier appointments and your errors and omissions underwriter may each add requirements, so confirm them before you set policy.
What checks should an insurance agency run?
Match the search to the risk of the role. Staff who handle premiums, client funds, or personal financial and health data carry the most exposure.
Core searches for producers, CSRs and account managers
- SSN trace: verifies identity and builds the list of names and counties to search.
- County criminal: court-level records for each county of residence, usually the most complete source.
- National criminal database: a broad sweep that helps find records in other jurisdictions.
- Federal criminal: catches federal court cases such as fraud and financial crimes.
- Sex-offender registry: relevant for in-home or vulnerable-client contact.
- Employment and education verification: confirms stated history and credentials.
- MVR: for anyone who drives for the agency, such as field adjusters or inspectors.
Most Reveal Background searches return the same day. Some county courts respond more slowly, so build a short buffer into your start dates.
How do the checks compare by role?
| Role | Criminal (county, national, federal) | SSN trace | Employment / education | MVR | Drug test |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Licensed producer | Yes | Yes | Yes | If driving | Per policy |
| Customer service / billing | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Per policy |
| Claims adjuster (field) | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Per policy |
| IT / data access | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | Per policy |
If your policy includes drug testing, American Screening Corp drug testing supplies can be paired with your background program.
What FCRA steps must you follow?
When you use a third-party screening company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. 1681 et seq.) treats the report as a consumer report. Section 1681b sets the employer duties. The FTC explains them in its guidance for employers, as of November 2026.
- Disclosure: give the applicant a stand-alone written notice that you may obtain a report. It must contain no extra language.
- Authorization: get written permission before ordering.
- Pre-adverse action: before rejecting or firing based on the report, send a copy of the report and the FTC's summary of rights.
- Waiting period: allow a reasonable time for the person to dispute errors. Five business days is a common practice.
- Adverse action notice: if you proceed, send a final notice with the screening company's contact details, a statement that it did not make the decision, and dispute rights.
How do fair chance and state limits affect your decision?
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act applies to criminal-record decisions. The EEOC's arrest and conviction resource page directs employers to weigh the nature and seriousness of the offense, the time that has passed, and the nature of the job. Use a documented, consistent assessment rather than a blanket rule.
Many states and cities add their own rules, such as ban-the-box timing, limits on reporting older records (some states apply seven-year limits), and bans on considering arrests that did not lead to conviction. Check the law where the employee works. Section 1033 is separate: it can still apply when a state fair chance rule would otherwise allow hiring, so consult counsel on conflicts.
Insurance agency screening checklist
- Confirm state insurance department and carrier requirements for your lines of business.
- Define which roles trigger which searches, and apply the policy uniformly.
- Use a stand-alone FCRA disclosure and written authorization.
- Run SSN trace, county, national and federal criminal searches.
- Verify employment and education for stated credentials.
- Order an MVR for any role that drives.
- Record the individualized assessment for any record found.
- Follow pre-adverse and adverse action steps every time.
- Store reports securely and limit access to those who need them.
- Rescreen on the schedule your policy sets, with fresh authorization where required.
How do you get started?
Reveal Background offers FCRA-compliant screening with no setup fee, and you pay per report. You can create an account to order background checks and begin the same day. Learn more at Reveal Background employment screening.
Frequently asked questions
Is a background check legally required for insurance agency employees?
No single federal law mandates a check, but 18 U.S.C. 1033 bars certain felons from insurance work without regulator consent. State licensing and carrier rules often require screening, so most agencies check every hire.
Which checks matter most for an insurance agency?
Criminal searches (county, national, federal) and an SSN trace come first, because dishonesty offenses matter most. Add employment and education verification, plus an MVR for driving roles.
How long does insurance employee screening take?
Reveal Background returns most searches the same day. County court searches can take longer depending on the court, so plan a short buffer before the start date.
What must we do before rejecting a candidate over a report?
Send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the summary of rights, wait a reasonable time for a dispute, then send the final adverse action notice.
Sources
- FTC: Using Consumer Reports: What Employers Need to Know
- EEOC: Arrest and Conviction Records resource page
- Cornell Law School LII: 18 U.S.C. 1033
This article is general information, not legal advice; consult counsel on adverse action and state-specific requirements.
Compare background check packages
Find screening options for the people and roles you hire for.
