Background Checks for Nonprofit Employees: What to Run

Screening guide
← Back to Resources

Quick answer: Nonprofit employers should run a Social Security number trace, county criminal searches, a national criminal database search and a sex-offender registry search before hire. Add MVR for drivers and employment or education verification for finance and leadership roles. Reveal Background returns most searches the same day, with no setup fee.

  • Match the search package to the role: the more access to money, vulnerable people or vehicles, the deeper the check.
  • The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA, 15 U.S.C. 1681) requires a stand-alone disclosure, written authorization and an adverse action process.
  • Reveal Background gives nonprofit hiring teams pay-per-report screening with no setup fee.

What should a nonprofit include in an employee background check?

Start with an SSN trace. It lists the names and addresses tied to a candidate's Social Security number, which tells you where to search for records.

Then run county criminal searches in each county of residence, plus a national criminal database search and a federal criminal search. The national database helps find records outside the counties you searched. It is not a replacement for county court checks.

Add the sex-offender registry search for any role with access to children, seniors or other vulnerable clients. Add an MVR (motor vehicle record) for anyone who drives for the organization.

Which searches fit which nonprofit roles?

Recommended search packages by nonprofit role
RoleCore searchesAdd when relevant
Program staff working with youth or seniorsSSN trace, county criminal, national criminal, sex-offender registryEmployment verification, state-required fingerprint checks
Finance, bookkeeping, developmentSSN trace, county criminal, federal criminal, national criminalEducation and employment verification
Drivers and transport staffSSN trace, county criminal, MVRDrug testing
Executive director and senior leadersSSN trace, county, federal, national criminalEducation and employment verification
Administrative and facilities staffSSN trace, county criminal, national criminalSex-offender registry if on-site with clients

What FCRA steps must a nonprofit follow?

When you use a third-party screening company, the report is a consumer report. The FTC explains the employer duties in its guidance on background checks and consumer reports (see Sources). Follow these steps in order.

  1. Give the candidate a written disclosure, in a document that is only the disclosure, saying you may obtain a report for employment.
  2. Get the candidate's written authorization before you order the report.
  3. Certify to the screening company that you have permissible purpose and will comply with equal employment laws.
  4. If you may decide against hiring because of the report, send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the summary of rights.
  5. Allow a reasonable time for the candidate to respond, then send the final adverse action notice if you proceed.

Volunteers are not always treated like employees under the FCRA, so ask counsel how your policy applies to each group.

How should a nonprofit use criminal records fairly?

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act applies to criminal-record screening. The EEOC resource page on arrest and conviction records lists the factors to weigh: the nature and seriousness of the offense, the time that has passed, and the nature of the job. Apply them to each role in writing and use the same standard for every candidate in that role.

Also check state and local fair chance laws, often called ban-the-box laws. Many limit when in the process you may ask about or consider criminal history. Some states and cities also cap how far back certain records can be reported, with seven years being a common limit. Rules differ by state and city, so confirm the one where the employee works.

How long does a nonprofit background check take?

Reveal Background returns most searches the same day. Timing depends on the search. County court records that require manual retrieval, and employment or education verifications that depend on third parties, can take longer. Build that into your offer timeline, and tell candidates what to expect.

Pre-hire checklist for nonprofit hiring teams

  • Define the search package for each role before posting the job.
  • Use a stand-alone FCRA disclosure and get signed authorization.
  • Check state and local fair chance and record-reporting limits.
  • Run SSN trace first, then search every county it reveals.
  • Add sex-offender registry and any state-required checks for client-facing roles.
  • Document how you weighed any record against the job.
  • Send pre-adverse and adverse action notices in order.
  • Keep reports confidential and store them securely.

How do you set up screening for a nonprofit?

Create an account at Reveal Background's screening platform, choose the searches for each role and invite candidates to authorize. There is no setup fee and you pay per report, which suits organizations with seasonal or irregular hiring. For roles that need a drug test, Reveal coordinates testing through American Screening Corp.

FAQ

Do nonprofits have to run background checks on employees?

No single federal rule requires it for every nonprofit. Some states, funders and insurers require checks for roles serving children or vulnerable adults. Confirm your obligations with counsel.

What does a nonprofit background check cost?

Reveal Background has no setup fee and charges per report. The cost depends on the searches you select, so build the package by role and order only what each role needs.

Can a nonprofit reject a candidate for a criminal record?

Yes, but weigh the offense's nature and seriousness, the time passed and the job's nature, and follow FCRA adverse action steps and any state or local fair chance law.

Is a national criminal database search enough?

No. It helps find records across jurisdictions but can be incomplete. Pair it with county criminal searches where the candidate has lived and worked.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal advice; consult counsel on adverse action and on state and local screening rules.

Compare background check packages

Find screening options for the people and roles you hire for.

View pricing

By submitting, I agree to Reveal Background’s Privacy Policy and to be contacted about my inquiry.

Contact our team
SEE REVEAL IN ACTION

A live demo.
Built around you.

See how Reveal Background can simplify screening for your team—from your first order to reviewing results.

  • Walk through screening packages, candidate invitations, and your dashboard.
  • Explore workplace, tenant, MVR, self, and international screening.
  • Discuss your needs and find a screening workflow that fits.
SCREENING FOR YOUR NEXT STEP
WorkplaceTenantMVRSelfInternational