Background Checks for Law Firm Employees: What to Run
Quick answer: Law firms should run an SSN trace, county, state and federal criminal searches, a national criminal database search, sex-offender registry check, and employment and education verification on every hire. Add an MVR for drivers. Get written disclosure and authorization first. Reveal Background provides these FCRA-compliant checks, with same-day results on most searches.
- Screen every role that touches client files, funds or systems, not only attorneys.
- Follow the FCRA sequence: standalone disclosure, written authorization, pre-adverse action, adverse action.
- Score criminal records against the job, not the label, and check state and local fair chance laws.
Why do law firms need background checks?
Law firms hold privileged communications, client funds and personal data. One bad hire can create malpractice exposure, a trust-account loss or a data breach.
Firms also have a duty to supervise nonlawyer staff, so a documented, consistent screening process is part of sound risk management. Consistency also protects you if a rejected candidate challenges a decision.
What searches should a law firm run?
Match the search to the access the role carries. Reveal Background employment screening covers the following searches, each defined here:
- County criminal search: court records in the counties where the candidate has lived or worked. It is the core criminal search.
- Federal criminal search: records from federal district courts, relevant for fraud and financial offenses.
- National criminal database search: a broad multi-jurisdiction search that helps find counties to check. It does not replace county court searches.
- Sex-offender registry search: checks registry records.
- SSN trace: returns names and addresses associated with a Social Security number, which helps decide where to search and flags identity mismatches.
- MVR (motor vehicle report): driving history, for roles that drive for the firm, such as couriers and process servers.
- Employment and education verification: confirms titles, dates and degrees stated on the resume.
Which checks fit which law firm role?
| Role | Core searches | Add when relevant |
|---|---|---|
| Attorney / associate | SSN trace, county and federal criminal, education and employment verification | Bar admission and discipline check in the state bar's public directory |
| Paralegal / legal assistant | SSN trace, county, federal and national criminal, employment verification | Education verification |
| Accounting / trust account staff | SSN trace, county, federal and national criminal, employment verification | Education verification |
| Receptionist / office admin | SSN trace, county criminal, national criminal, sex-offender registry | Employment verification |
| IT / records staff | SSN trace, county, federal and national criminal | Employment verification |
| Courier / process server | County criminal, sex-offender registry, MVR | Drug screen |
What are the FCRA steps for law firm hiring?
A background report from a screening company is a consumer report under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA, 15 U.S.C. 1681). Employers must follow set steps, as described in the FTC's guidance for employers on using consumer reports.
- Give the candidate a clear, standalone written disclosure that you may obtain a report.
- Obtain written authorization before ordering.
- Order the report through your Reveal Background account.
- If the report may lead you to reject the candidate, send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and the summary of rights.
- Allow a reasonable time for the candidate to dispute errors.
- If you proceed, send the final adverse action notice with the required FCRA content.
How should a firm weigh criminal records?
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act applies to employer use of criminal records. The EEOC's arrest and conviction resource page points employers to the nature and seriousness of the offense, the time that has passed, and the nature of the job. Treat an arrest without a conviction with particular caution.
Many states and cities also have ban-the-box or fair chance laws that limit when you can ask about or consider criminal history, and some limit how far back reports may go. Check your state and local rules by name before you set policy.
Should a law firm drug test?
Drug testing is a policy choice for most firms. If you test, apply the same rule to every candidate in a role and put it in writing. Reveal coordinates employer drug testing through American Screening Corp.
Law firm screening checklist
- Write a screening policy listing searches by role.
- Use the standalone FCRA disclosure and written authorization for every candidate.
- Verify bar status directly with the state bar for attorneys.
- Confirm that county searches cover every county in the candidate's history.
- Review records individually against the job, using the Title VII factors.
- Follow pre-adverse and adverse action steps every time.
- Keep reports confidential and store them separately from the personnel file.
- Re-screen on the schedule your policy sets, applied to everyone in the role.
FAQ
What background check should a law firm run on a new paralegal?
Run an SSN trace, county and federal criminal searches, a national criminal database search and employment verification. Add education verification if the role requires a degree or certificate.
Do law firms need written consent for background checks?
Yes. The FCRA requires a standalone written disclosure and the candidate's written authorization before you obtain a consumer report for employment purposes.
Can a law firm reject a candidate for a criminal record?
Sometimes. Consider the offense, the time passed and the job duties, follow state and local fair chance laws, and complete the FCRA pre-adverse and adverse action steps.
How long does a law firm background check take?
Reveal Background returns same-day results on most searches. County court searches and verifications that depend on outside sources can take longer.
Sources
- FTC: Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know
- EEOC: Arrest and Conviction Records resource page
- Cornell Law School LII: 15 U.S.C. 1681b, permissible purposes of consumer reports
This is general information, not legal or medical advice; consult counsel on adverse action and state-specific requirements.
Compare background check packages
Find screening options for the people and roles you hire for.
